Sesame 3-ways Sugar Cookie

Jump to recipe



My next cookie is based on an Internet famous cookie – the infamous cookie goddess Sarah Keiffer’s Neapolitan Cookies ! She has included them in her first cookbook – 100 Cookies, which is my daughter’s highly used cookbook. My daughter has made her brownies, brown butter chocolate chip cookies, and a few others, without any assistance from me.


Her cookies became a viral sensation, and they are so pretty to look at too, with the cream, pink and brown colors. My cookies are adapted from her recipe, but they are not neapolitan cookies! They are slightly different. They are based on one of my favorite ingredients – sesame!

sesame 3-way sugar cookie


My inspiration comes from the sesame brittle or chikki that is widely available by street hawkers in Mumbai and Pune. They are a hard candy, made with white sesame seeds and jaggery and a little bit of ghee. That is it.

Growing up, we would go often to Pune or Lonavala, which were within 2 to 3 hours driving distance from Mumbai. We would buy the different kinds of chikki available from the stores in these cities – like peanut chikki, sesame chikki, channa chikki and so on. 


Few years ago I made a black sesame chikki with black sesame seeds and jaggery. I had put pieces of this brittle in a black sesame ice cream that I had made. This was one of my favorite flavors back then!




The most obvious difference between black and white sesame seeds will be the color. The color difference results from the fact that black sesame seeds are unhulled, while white sesame seeds have had their hulls removed to reveal the white inner parts of the seeds. You can read more about it here



Some of the benefits of sesame seeds are:

  1. Good Source of Fiber
  2. May Lower Cholesterol and Triglycerides
  3. Nutritious Source of Plant Protein
  4. May Help Lower Blood Pressure
  5. May Support Healthy Bones
  6. May Reduce Inflammation
  7. Good Source of B Vitamins
  8. May Aid Blood Cell Formation


You can find this information on

sesame 3-way sugar cookie


Here are the list of ingredients that are used in the cookie dough:

  • Dry ingredients: All purpose flour, baking soda and salt. The baking soda helps the cookie spread.
  • Unsalted Butter: Always make sure that the butter is at room temperature.
  • Granulated Sugar: Helps to get those crispy edges on a cookie.
  • Egg and egg yolk: Helps to bind the cookie dough and also give it texture.
  • Vanilla extract: I always use a lot in my bakes because so much flavor comes from a simple ingredient like vanilla extract.



My cookie uses sesame in 3 ways:

  • Original Tahini : Available at Trader Joe’s or any middle eastern market.
  • Black Tahini : Available on Amazon
  • Halvah + Rose Water + Pink food gel : Halvah is available on Amazon or any middle eastern market.

sesame 3-way sugar cookie

The black tahini is linked here.


The Halvah is linked here.


The dough is divided into 3 equal parts. Each part is mixed in the stand mixer with one of the above ingredients, to get a cream, black and pink dough.


I use a 1 tablespoon cookie scoop, to scoop out each colored dough to get equal portions. I got this idea from Michelle’s blog post! Love the idea of using the 1 tablespoon cookie scoop! I take one colored scoop from each of the three doughs and bind it together to form one ball. Roll it out in sugar and place it on a baking sheet, and bake for 10-11 minutes.


The cookie is garnished immediately with white and black sesame seeds, halvah and edible dried rose petals.


This cookie is the chef’s kiss! I am blown away by HOW GOOD THIS COOKIE IS. Even my non-sesame loving husband LOVED This cookie, which says a lot to me! 


Please try this cookie and thank me later! It is absolutely divine and will be a crowd pleaser!

sesame 3-way sugar cookie


If you want a smaller cookie, you can use a ½ tablespoon cookie scoop, and make smaller balls, to make smaller cookies. Bake time will vary – maybe to 6-8 minutes (you would have to try it out!). Butttt you will get more cookies out of this one batch!


Hope you get to try this cookie! If you do, please tag #thejamlab on Instagram and/or leave a comment on this blog post! 





Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Never Miss a recipe from the Jamlab